So, you’re staring at your shower shelf, two bottles in hand: purple shampoo and blue shampoo. Both promising to banish brassiness, but each with a slightly different hue. The question nagging at you is: what happens if you decide to mix them? Is it a recipe for hair-toning perfection, or a path to a color correction disaster? Let’s dive deep into the world of color theory, hair science, and the potential outcomes of this shampoo experiment.
Understanding Purple and Blue Shampoo: A Color Theory Crash Course
Before we mix anything, it’s crucial to understand what these shampoos are designed to do individually. They aren’t just fancy colored liquids; they’re based on the principles of color theory.
The Science Behind Toning Shampoos
Hair color, especially blonde, silver, or highlighted hair, is prone to developing unwanted yellow or orange tones. This brassiness is caused by oxidation, mineral deposits in water, and sun exposure. Purple and blue shampoos work to counteract these tones, utilizing the color wheel.
Purple sits opposite yellow on the color wheel. This means that purple pigment neutralizes yellow tones. Purple shampoo deposits a small amount of purple dye onto the hair shaft, effectively canceling out the yellow and leaving the hair looking cooler and brighter.
Blue shampoo, on the other hand, is designed to neutralize orange tones. Orange is the opposite of blue on the color wheel. Blue shampoo deposits blue pigment, counteracting the orange and leaving the hair with a more neutral or ashy tone.
It’s all about complementary colors. Complementary colors are pairs of colors which, when combined or mixed, cancel each other out by producing a neutral gray or white. This is the core principle behind these toning shampoos.
Who Should Use Which?
The effectiveness of purple or blue shampoo depends on your hair color and the specific brassy tones you are trying to combat.
Purple shampoo is generally recommended for those with blonde, platinum, silver, or lightened brown hair that is experiencing yellow tones. It’s the go-to for maintaining a bright, cool blonde.
Blue shampoo is best suited for brunettes with highlights or balayage, or those with darker blonde hair that is pulling orange tones. It can also be used on darker hair that has been bleached to a level where orange tones are prominent.
Understanding your starting hair color and the unwanted tones you’re fighting is the first step in choosing the right shampoo.
Mixing Purple and Blue Shampoo: Potential Outcomes
Now, let’s get to the heart of the matter: what happens when you combine these color-correcting powerhouses? The answer, as with many things in the beauty world, isn’t always straightforward. It largely depends on the ratio of each shampoo, your starting hair color, and the porosity of your hair.
Neutralization Nirvana or Muddy Mayhem?
In theory, mixing purple and blue shampoo could create a more balanced toning effect, neutralizing both yellow and orange tones simultaneously. This could be beneficial if your hair has a mix of both brassy hues.
However, there’s a significant risk of over-toning or creating a muddy, dull appearance. If you use too much of either shampoo, or if your hair is highly porous (meaning it absorbs color quickly), you could end up with a lavender or greenish tinge. Greenish tones occur when excessive blue pigment is deposited on hair, especially on lighter blonde shades.
The biggest risk is the potential for an uneven result. It’s difficult to control the exact amount of pigment being deposited, and some areas of your hair might absorb more color than others.
Factors Affecting the Outcome
Several factors can influence the results of your shampoo concoction.
-
Hair Porosity: High porosity hair absorbs color quickly and easily, making it more prone to over-toning. Low porosity hair resists color absorption, potentially requiring longer processing times.
-
Starting Hair Color: The lighter your hair, the more susceptible it is to color changes. Very light blonde or platinum hair can quickly turn purple or blue if the shampoo mixture is too strong or left on for too long.
-
Shampoo Ratio: The ratio of purple to blue shampoo will significantly impact the final result. More purple will lean towards neutralizing yellow, while more blue will target orange.
-
Processing Time: Leaving the mixture on for too long will intensify the toning effect, increasing the risk of over-toning.
When Mixing Might Be Okay (and When It’s a Definite No-No)
There are a few scenarios where mixing purple and blue shampoo might be acceptable, but it’s generally best left to experienced colorists.
If you have a good understanding of your hair’s porosity and undertones, and you’re confident in your ability to control the ratio and processing time, you could try a very small, diluted mixture. Start with a predominantly purple shampoo base and add a tiny amount of blue shampoo, focusing on the areas that tend to pull more orange.
However, if you’re unsure about any of these factors, it’s best to avoid mixing. It’s far safer to use each shampoo separately, targeting specific areas of concern.
A Safer Approach: Targeted Toning
Instead of mixing, consider a more strategic approach to toning your hair. Targeted toning involves using purple or blue shampoo individually, focusing on specific areas of your hair that need the most correction.
Identifying Your Hair’s Undertones
The key to targeted toning is accurately identifying the undertones in your hair. Examine your hair in natural light. Do you see more yellow or more orange? Are the brassy tones concentrated in certain areas, like around your face or at the ends?
If you primarily see yellow tones, stick with purple shampoo. If you’re noticing orange tones, use blue shampoo. If you have a mix of both, consider alternating between the two shampoos on different washes.
Applying Toning Shampoos Effectively
When applying toning shampoo, focus on the areas that need the most attention. You can even apply different shampoos to different sections of your hair. For example, you might use purple shampoo on your roots to combat yellow tones and blue shampoo on your ends to neutralize orange.
Always follow the instructions on the shampoo bottle and start with a short processing time, gradually increasing it as needed. Keep a close eye on your hair while the shampoo is processing, and rinse immediately if you notice any unwanted color changes.
What to Do if You Mess Up
Even with the best intentions, mistakes can happen. If you accidentally over-tone your hair or end up with an unwanted tint, don’t panic.
Clarifying Shampoo to the Rescue
The first step is to use a clarifying shampoo. Clarifying shampoo is designed to remove buildup and impurities from the hair, including excess pigment. Wash your hair thoroughly with clarifying shampoo, and repeat if necessary.
Be aware that clarifying shampoo can be drying, so follow up with a moisturizing conditioner or hair mask.
Color Correction with a Professional
If clarifying shampoo doesn’t do the trick, it’s time to consult a professional colorist. They have the expertise and tools to correct any unwanted tones and restore your hair to its desired color.
Trying to fix a color correction problem yourself can often make things worse, so it’s best to leave it to the professionals.
Preventing Brassiness: Long-Term Strategies
The best way to avoid color correction mishaps is to prevent brassiness in the first place. There are several steps you can take to maintain your hair color and keep it looking fresh and vibrant.
Protect Your Hair from the Sun
Sun exposure can accelerate oxidation and contribute to brassiness. Wear a hat or use a hair product with UV protection when you’re spending time outdoors.
Use Sulfate-Free Shampoos
Sulfates can strip the hair of its natural oils and fade color. Opt for sulfate-free shampoos to prolong the life of your hair color.
Invest in a Water Filter
Mineral deposits in water can also contribute to brassiness. Consider installing a shower filter to remove these minerals and protect your hair color.
Regular Toning Treatments
In addition to purple and blue shampoo, you can also use toning masks or glosses to maintain your hair color. These treatments provide a more intense toning effect and can help keep brassiness at bay.
Ultimately, mixing purple and blue shampoo is a risky endeavor that’s best avoided. Understanding your hair’s undertones and using targeted toning techniques is a much safer and more effective approach. And remember, when in doubt, consult a professional colorist. They can provide personalized advice and help you achieve your hair color goals without any unwanted surprises.
Will mixing purple and blue shampoo create a super toning powerhouse?
While the idea of combining purple and blue shampoo for enhanced toning might seem appealing, it’s generally not recommended. Purple shampoo neutralizes yellow tones, while blue shampoo targets orange tones in hair. Mixing them could potentially lead to uneven toning, resulting in some areas appearing more ashy or even developing a muddy, unnatural color. It’s crucial to address specific undertones individually rather than attempting a one-size-fits-all solution.
The effectiveness of toning shampoos depends on your hair’s porosity, the concentration of pigments, and the duration of application. Mixing purple and blue shampoo makes it difficult to control these factors, increasing the risk of over-toning or ending up with inconsistent results. Furthermore, the combined ingredients might react unpredictably, potentially drying out or damaging your hair more than using either shampoo separately.
What hair colors benefit most from a combined purple and blue shampoo?
Theoretically, hair colors with both yellow and orange undertones could benefit, but the execution is extremely tricky. This scenario is relatively rare; typically, hair leans more towards one set of undertones than the other. Think of a very faded level 7 or 8 blonde that has both brassy and orange hues.
However, using a mixed shampoo in such a case is still not the ideal approach. The best strategy is to identify the dominant undertone and address it with the appropriate shampoo (purple for yellow, blue for orange). For areas with mixed undertones, consider alternating between purple and blue shampoos in separate washes or even spot-treating specific sections of hair.
Can mixing these shampoos cause hair damage?
While mixing purple and blue shampoos doesn’t inherently cause chemical damage like bleaching, it can indirectly lead to dryness and brittleness. Both shampoos often contain sulfates or other cleansing agents that, when used excessively or improperly, can strip the hair of its natural oils. Combining the two amplifies this effect, potentially leaving your hair feeling rough and difficult to manage.
Moreover, over-toning can create an ashy or dull appearance, making the hair look and feel unhealthy. This is especially true if your hair is already dry or damaged. To mitigate these risks, use toning shampoos sparingly, always follow up with a moisturizing conditioner, and avoid overlapping treatments unless you are absolutely sure of what you are doing and your hair’s specific needs.
What’s the best way to correct a color mishap caused by mixing purple and blue shampoo?
The first step is to assess the damage. If your hair is simply too ashy, a clarifying shampoo can help remove some of the excess pigment. Follow this with a deep conditioning treatment to replenish moisture and restore shine. Avoid further toning treatments until your hair has recovered.
If the color is significantly uneven or muddy, consult a professional colorist. They can analyze your hair’s current state and formulate a personalized color correction plan. Attempting to fix a complex color issue yourself can often worsen the problem, leading to further damage and frustration. Professionals have the experience and expertise to safely and effectively restore your desired color.
Are there any situations where mixing these shampoos might be acceptable?
In extremely rare and very specific situations, a highly experienced colorist might intentionally mix very precise ratios of purple and blue shampoo to achieve a nuanced tonal effect. This is not something to attempt at home without expert knowledge and a clear understanding of color theory and your hair’s unique characteristics.
This approach would only be viable if the hair presents a very specific combination of yellow and orange undertones, requiring a very fine-tuned color correction strategy. Even then, the colorist would likely prefer layering or alternating the shampoos rather than creating a permanent mixture. The risk of unintended consequences is simply too high for at-home experimentation.
What are the alternatives to mixing purple and blue shampoo for achieving desired hair color?
Instead of mixing, consider alternating between purple and blue shampoos on separate wash days. This allows you to target specific undertones more effectively. You can also use each shampoo on different sections of your hair, focusing purple shampoo on areas with yellow tones and blue shampoo on areas with orange tones.
Another option is to use a color-depositing conditioner instead of or in addition to shampoo. These conditioners provide a gentler toning effect and are often less drying than shampoos. For more stubborn undertones, consult a professional colorist for a personalized toning treatment or a glaze that will effectively neutralize the unwanted tones without causing damage.
How do I determine if my hair needs purple or blue shampoo (or both)?
The key is to identify the undertones present in your hair. Yellow undertones are common in lighter blondes, especially when the toner fades. Blue shampoo is specifically formulated to neutralize orange tones, which are often found in brunettes or darker blondes that have been lightened.
Examine your hair in natural light to accurately assess the undertones. If you see mainly yellow, purple shampoo is the right choice. If you see orange, opt for blue shampoo. If you’re unsure or suspect both are present, start with one type and observe the results before using the other. Remember to use these products sparingly and always follow with a moisturizing conditioner.